OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Folding Knife Review

Putting the OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife Through Its Paces

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife is a classic slip joint pocketknife that harkens back to simpler times. Made by OTTER-Messer, a company with a long history of knife making in Germany, this particular model stands out with its carbon steel blade, smoked oak handle, and prominent anchor inlay. It’s a knife that appeals to those who appreciate traditional design and quality materials.

I’ve always been drawn to simple, functional tools. I was looking for a reliable everyday carry knife that didn’t scream “tactical” but could still handle a variety of tasks. The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife seemed to fit the bill perfectly.

Upon unboxing, I was immediately struck by the classic lines and solid feel of the knife. The smoked oak handle feels warm and comfortable in the hand, and the carbon steel blade has a beautiful satin finish. The build quality feels robust, promising years of faithful service.

Compared to modern, locking blade knives, the OTTER-Messer’s slip joint mechanism might seem outdated to some. I also considered a Benchmade Griptilian and a Spyderco Paramilitary 2, but ultimately, I wanted something more traditional and less aggressive in appearance. The OTTER-Messer won out because of its old-world charm and high-quality materials.

I was excited to add this knife to my EDC rotation. Its simple design and quality materials gave me confidence that it would perform well, even though it lacks some of the modern features found in other knives.

Real-World Testing: Putting OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife to the Test

First Use Experience

I first tested the OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife on a weekend camping trip in the Allegheny National Forest. It handled everything from preparing food to whittling kindling with ease. The carbon steel blade proved to be incredibly sharp and held its edge well.

The knife performed admirably, even in damp conditions. I used it to feather sticks for a fire, and the oak handle remained grippy despite the moisture. The slip joint mechanism operated smoothly, providing confidence during use.

There was a slight learning curve with the slip joint mechanism. I’m used to locking blades, but after a few uses, I grew accustomed to being mindful of the blade during use. I was pleasantly surprised by how well the knife handled more demanding tasks despite not having a locking mechanism.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several months of regular use, the OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife has proven to be a reliable companion. The blade has retained its edge well, requiring only occasional stropping. The handle has also held up nicely, showing no signs of cracking or splitting.

The blade has developed a nice patina, which is to be expected with carbon steel. I’ve made a conscious effort to wipe it down after each use to prevent rust, and it has required minimal maintenance overall. The slip joint remains smooth and reliable.

Compared to my experience with stainless steel blades, the carbon steel requires more care to prevent rust. However, the superior edge retention of the carbon steel makes the extra effort worthwhile. This OTTER-Messer has exceeded my expectations in terms of performance and durability.

Breaking Down the Features of OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife

Specifications

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife boasts a 3.13-inch satin finish carbon steel blade. The blade’s carbon steel composition gives it excellent edge retention and makes it easy to sharpen.

The knife measures 4 inches closed, making it convenient for everyday carry. The smoked oak handle provides a comfortable and secure grip.

It features stainless steel bolsters that add to the knife’s durability and classic aesthetic. The inlay shield prominently displays an anchor, a nod to OTTER-Messer’s maritime history.

The knife uses a slip joint mechanism, a traditional design that relies on spring pressure to keep the blade open or closed. A leather lanyard strap is included for added convenience and style.

These specifications translate to a well-balanced and functional knife that’s ideal for everyday carry. The classic design and quality materials enhance the overall user experience.

Performance & Functionality

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife performs exceptionally well for a variety of cutting tasks. Its sharp carbon steel blade makes quick work of slicing, whittling, and general utility work.

The knife’s strengths lie in its sharp blade, comfortable handle, and simple, reliable design. However, the slip joint mechanism may not be suitable for heavy-duty tasks.

The knife meets my expectations as a reliable everyday carry tool. It is not designed for tactical applications, but for everyday tasks, it is a great choice.

Design & Ergonomics

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife features a classic and elegant design. The smoked oak handle provides a comfortable and secure grip. The weight feels balanced in hand.

The knife is user-friendly, with a simple design that requires no learning curve. The slip joint mechanism is easy to operate, and the blade opens and closes smoothly.

Durability & Maintenance

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife is built to last. The carbon steel blade is durable and holds its edge well, and the oak handle is sturdy and resistant to cracking.

Maintenance is relatively simple. Keeping the blade clean and lightly oiled is essential to prevent rust. The slip joint mechanism requires occasional cleaning and lubrication to ensure smooth operation.

Accessories and Customization Options

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife comes with a leather lanyard strap. There are no other included accessories.

Customization options are limited due to the knife’s traditional design. However, the lanyard strap can be replaced with different colors or materials. While aftermarket scales are not widely available due to the construction method, some skilled custom knife makers may be able to create replacements. Aftermarket pocket clips are not compatible due to the design of the knife.

Pros and Cons of OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife

Who Should Buy OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife?

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife is perfect for those who appreciate traditional knife designs and quality materials. It’s ideal for everyday carry, light utility work, and those who enjoy whittling or other traditional crafts. This is also an excellent gift for knife collectors and enthusiasts who appreciate historical designs.

This knife is not suitable for those who require a heavy-duty, locking blade for demanding tasks. It may also not be the best choice for those who live in humid environments or who are not diligent about knife maintenance.

A must-have accessory is a quality honing steel or strop to maintain the blade’s edge. A good quality knife oil will help prevent rust.

Conclusion on OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife

The OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife is a well-made and attractive knife that offers excellent performance for everyday carry. Its sharp carbon steel blade, comfortable handle, and classic design make it a joy to use.

At $88.49, the price is justified given the quality of materials and craftsmanship. It’s a knife that will likely last for many years with proper care.

I would definitely recommend the OTTER-Messer 172ML Carbon Steel Large Anchor Folding Knife to anyone looking for a reliable and aesthetically pleasing everyday carry knife. If you appreciate tradition and quality, this knife is a great choice. Add one to your collection today!