Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster with Body Shield Review

Full Disclosure: Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield

The Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield is an ambidextrous, leather outside-the-waistband (OWB) holster designed for comfortable carry and quick access. Crafted by Gould & Goodrich, a name synonymous with quality law enforcement gear, this holster aims to balance accessibility, concealment, and firearm protection. With its removable body shield and versatile clip/loop design, it promises adaptability for various carry preferences, making it a potential solution for both professional and civilian users.

My interest in this holster stemmed from a need for a reliable and comfortable OWB option for my Sig P238. I’ve often found OWB holsters bulky or uncomfortable, so I was looking for a solution that offered a secure fit without sacrificing all-day comfort. The body shield was also a key selling point, as I value having a barrier between the firearm and my skin for both comfort and preventing snagging on clothing.

Upon unboxing, I was immediately impressed by the quality of the leather. The stitching was clean and even, and the leather felt substantial without being overly stiff. The holster felt lightweight and well-constructed, lending an initial sense of confidence in its durability and I was happy that it fit my Sig P238 perfectly.

Compared to other OWB holsters I’ve used, like some Kydex models from Alien Gear or a hybrid holster from Crossbreed, the Gould & Goodrich offered a different approach to comfort and concealment. The Kydex holsters tended to be very rigid and less comfortable against the skin. The hybrid holster was comfortable, but too bulky for my needs. I was particularly drawn to the Gould & Goodrich because of the leather’s inherent flexibility and the promise of a more comfortable carry experience, while still retaining good retention.

My first impression was cautiously optimistic. The quality seemed evident, and the design looked promising, but the true test would be how it performed under real-world conditions.

Real-World Testing: Putting Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield to the Test

First Use Experience

I initially tested the Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield at my local shooting range during a standard practice session. I wore it with a 1.5-inch leather gun belt, both using the clip attachment and threading the belt through the belt loops. The range environment provided a controlled setting to evaluate draw speed, retention, and overall comfort during movement.

The holster performed well in relatively dry conditions. Drawing from the holster was smooth and consistent, and re-holstering was easy. I also noticed no noticeable discomfort or printing, even when bending or squatting.

There was one minor issue in that the clip was a bit tight to be worn inside the waistband with my regular pants. I had to loosen my belt to be able to draw the weapon smoothly, which caused some concern.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of regular use, including daily carry and additional range sessions, the Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield continued to perform admirably. The leather molded slightly to the shape of my firearm, resulting in a more snug and secure fit. The suede lining helped protect the finish of my Sig P238.

Despite daily wear and exposure to varying temperatures, the holster has shown minimal signs of wear and tear. The stitching remains intact, and the leather hasn’t stretched or deformed significantly. The body shield still provides adequate protection and comfort against my skin.

Maintaining the holster has been simple. I occasionally wipe it down with a damp cloth and apply a leather conditioner to keep the leather supple. Compared to previous holsters, this Gould & Goodrich holster has proven to be both more comfortable and easier to maintain.

Breaking Down the Features of Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield

Specifications

• Manufacturer: Gould & Goodrich
• Gun Make: SIG Sauer (specifically designed for the P238)
• Hand: Ambidextrous
• Holster Type: Belt Holster (OWB)
• Holster Material: Leather
• Light/Laser Attachment: No
• Accessory Attachment System: Belt Loop / Clip
• Finish: Plain
• Quantity: 1
• Belt Loop/Snap Width: 1.75 inches
• Fastener/Closure Type: Open Top
• Age Group: Adults
• Holster Finish: Plain
• Gun Type: Revolver
• Fabric/Material: Leather

These specifications highlight the holster’s focus on simplicity and versatility. The ambidextrous design makes it suitable for both left- and right-handed users, while the leather construction ensures durability and comfort.

Performance & Functionality

The Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield performs its primary function of securely carrying a firearm exceptionally well. Retention is secure, preventing accidental dislodging, yet the draw stroke remains smooth and efficient.

The holster’s design allows for a full firing grip before drawing, which enhances safety and speed. The open-top design allows for quick access to the firearm in high-pressure situations.

However, the lack of adjustable retention might be a drawback for some users who prefer a more customized draw resistance.

Design & Ergonomics

The holster’s design prioritizes both comfort and concealment. The leather body shield effectively prevents the firearm from rubbing against the wearer’s skin, enhancing comfort during extended carry.

The holster’s relatively slim profile minimizes printing, making it suitable for concealed carry under loose-fitting clothing. The ambidextrous design is a significant plus for left-handed shooters, which are often an afterthought in holster design.

Durability & Maintenance

The Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield is constructed from high-quality leather, which suggests excellent long-term durability. The reinforced stitching and sturdy belt clip contribute to its overall robust construction.

Maintaining the holster is relatively simple. Regular cleaning with a leather cleaner and conditioner will help keep the leather supple and prevent cracking or drying.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield is a fairly streamlined design. It does not come with any additional accessories.

The removable clip and belt loops allow for versatile carry options. However, the holster is not compatible with light or laser attachments due to its specific design for the Sig P238.

Pros and Cons of Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield

Who Should Buy Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield?

The Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield is perfect for individuals seeking a comfortable and concealable OWB holster for their Sig P238. It’s particularly well-suited for those who value leather construction, ambidextrous functionality, and a low-profile design.

Those who require adjustable retention or need to accommodate weapon-mounted lights/lasers should consider other options.

A sturdy 1.5-inch gun belt is a must-have accessory for optimal comfort and stability. Leather conditioner will help maintain the holster’s appearance and longevity.

Conclusion on Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield

The Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield offers a compelling blend of comfort, concealment, and durability. At $46.99, it represents excellent value for those seeking a reliable OWB holster for their Sig P238.

I would personally recommend this holster to anyone looking for a comfortable and versatile OWB carry option. The quality of the leather, the ambidextrous design, and the secure retention make it a solid choice for both experienced shooters and those new to concealed carry. If you prioritize comfort, concealment, and durability in a leather OWB holster, the Gould & Goodrich OWB Belt Holster w/ Body Shield is definitely worth considering. Give it a try and experience the difference a quality holster can make.